Sayuri–Chairman relationship
Memoirs of a GeishaThe relationship between Sayuri and the Chairman transforms a childhood encounter and years of unspoken longing into a shared life, but not into an uncomplicated happy ending. The Chairman tells Sayuri that he did not take her away from Nobu: Nobu gave her up. Recalling Sayuri’s desperate expression at the arranged meeting with the Minister, he says it reminded him of the frightened girl he had seen years earlier by the Shirakawa Stream. His account gives their union the shape of a rescue, while Sayuri’s later recollections show what that rescue asked her to surrender: her place in Gion, her hope of Nobu’s forgiveness, and eventually the Chairman himself.
From Recognition to Intimacy
The decisive change begins when the Chairman connects the woman before him to the child he remembers. He explains that seeing Sayuri with the Minister recalled her childhood look of desperation, as though she might drown without someone to save her. After learning from Pumpkin that the meeting had been intended for Nobu to witness, he decided to tell Nobu what he had seen. Nobu’s angry response convinced him that a man unable to forgive Sayuri was not truly her destiny. The Chairman thus describes his decision not as taking Sayuri from his friend but as responding to what he understood about both her distress and Nobu’s refusal.
Sayuri receives this explanation through an earlier memory of a boy named Gisuke who had climbed too high in a tree to jump into a shallow pond. Unable to climb down, he fell; his father, Mr. Yamashita, caught him. Sayuri now understands the astonishment and relief she had seen in the boy, because she feels herself falling toward danger and the Chairman gathering her into his arms. The childhood rescue recollection makes her intimacy with the Chairman feel like the completion of an old pattern: she had once watched another person be caught, and now experiences herself as the one saved.
The scene’s tenderness is not detached from bodily urgency. Still tearful and unable to wipe her face, Sayuri feels the Chairman draw close and kiss the skin at the opening of her kimono. She associates the intensity of his desire with a childhood memory of a maid secretly eating a ripe pear, its juice running down her neck. The comparison joins longing to appetite, making the encounter both an emotional rescue in Sayuri’s understanding and a physical, immediate union.
Shared Life and Emotional Shelter
Sayuri later identifies the evening with the Chairman as the point when the grieving voices within her fell silent. Before it, she had experienced life as a succession of obstacles and struggles, each demanding vigilance. After he became her danna, life softened. She describes herself as a tree whose roots had finally reached rich, wet soil beneath the surface. The image does not erase the hardship that preceded their relationship; it registers the relief of inhabiting a life that no longer seemed defined solely by resistance.
Their bond takes practical form in regular time together. In the spring of the year after Sayuri becomes his mistress, the Chairman buys Eishin-an, a luxurious house in northeastern Kyoto intended for company guests. He and Sayuri meet there three or four nights a week, sometimes more. On busy days he arrives late and wants a hot bath while she talks to him before he sleeps. More often he comes around sunset, eats dinner, and speaks with her as servants light the garden lanterns. Their intimacy is built not only from heightened encounters but from repeated evenings and the ordinary attention of a shared routine.
The Chairman often begins by talking through the troubles of his workday, including problems with a new product or a traffic accident involving a truckload of parts. Sayuri understands that he is using speech to clear his mind rather than asking her to solve these problems. She listens for the softening tone of his voice, then changes the subject when he seems ready. Their conversations move from work to the day’s incidents, films they have watched, or amusing stories from Mameha. Sayuri’s account emphasizes her attentiveness to the shift in his mood and the quiet pleasure of helping him leave work behind.
The Price of Their Arrangement
The Chairman’s decision to make Sayuri his danna does not restore her former place in Gion. His negotiations with Mother last several months, and their outcome binds Sayuri’s departure from geisha work to the Nitta household’s financial interests. The Chairman is already married and will not marry Sayuri. He wants her out of Gion so Nobu will not have to see her, but Mother will not let her leave the Nitta family without compensation. He therefore agrees to pay the okiya a considerable monthly sum on the condition that Mother allow Sayuri to end her career.
Sayuri remains living in the okiya, but the work and public rhythms that had defined her life there stop. She no longer attends school in the mornings, makes the rounds of Gion on special occasions, or entertains in the evenings. Her position is neither that of a working geisha nor that of a wife: the Chairman’s existing marriage prevents the latter, while his wish to keep her out of Nobu’s sight rules out her former public life. Their private relationship gives Sayuri the love she has pursued, but situates that love within an arrangement shaped by money, marriage, and concealment.
Leaving the profession does not leave Sayuri indifferent to what she has lost. She had become a geisha to win the Chairman’s affection, so she might have expected retirement to carry no grief. Instead, she remembers friendships with women and men she knew through Gion, and feels jealous when she sees geisha hurrying together to their next engagements, laughing about the last. She does not envy the uncertainty of their lives; she misses the promise of an evening still to come. Her relationship with the Chairman fulfills her central desire while narrowing her access to the social world in which much of her life had unfolded.
Nobu, Mameha, and the Limits of Fulfillment
The relationship also leaves Sayuri separated from Nobu. She recognizes that in banishing him from her life she has, in effect, banished herself from Gion. Her reflection links the fracture to a friendship’s difficult logic: winning something a friend covets can damage the friendship, just as her adoption had left the friendship between herself and Pumpkin unable to recover. The Chairman’s reassurance that Nobu gave her up changes how she understands his own choice, but it does not undo the rupture or return her to her former community.
Sayuri continues to hope that Nobu will forgive her, even as the hope wounds her. She eventually stops asking Mameha whether Nobu has inquired about her, because Mameha’s sigh and sad look make the answer painful. At the same time, Sayuri and Mameha remain close. They have tea several times a week, and Sayuri gives her a silk painting of an eighteenth-century woman teaching a girl calligraphy because the teacher’s benevolent face reminds her of Mameha. The gift and their continued meetings show that Sayuri’s life with the Chairman does not replace every other attachment; it exists alongside the friendship and gratitude she retains for the woman who guided her.
The Chairman’s account of Sayuri’s despair offers a reason he regards Nobu as unable to be her destiny, but Sayuri’s later experience resists the idea that being chosen resolves every loss. She is loved and sheltered, yet she remains conscious of the cost to her friendship with Nobu and her professional life. Her recollections make the relationship less a neat reward for lifelong devotion than a binding choice whose tenderness and damage remain inseparable.
Memory, Mortality, and Afterlife
The Chairman and Sayuri’s shared life continues at Eishin-an into his old age. Sayuri remembers his frailty and dreams of an elderly man whose beloved wife remains alive within him through the pleasure of their time together. In the dream, she drinks an extraordinary soup and feels that those who have died or left her continue to live within her: her sister Satsu, her parents, Mr. Tanaka, Nobu, and the Chairman. She wakes in tears and takes the Chairman’s hand, afraid she will not be able to live without him. Only a few months later he dies, and Sayuri understands his leaving as natural as leaves falling from trees.
In retrospect, the Chairman’s importance extends beyond the years they spend together. Sayuri says that even after his death she still has him in the richness of her memories, and that telling her story has allowed her to live through her life again. The relationship’s final form is therefore neither public marriage nor permanent physical presence. It is a remembered intimacy through which past attachments remain part of her, even as she accepts that the world and the people in it cannot be held unchanged.